AI Visibility: How to Check and Measure It (Free Method)

AI visibility is how often ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and other assistants name your business when customers ask for a recommendation. Here is how to measure it properly, by hand or with a free test, without being fooled by a single lucky or unlucky answer.

AmIPicked · 11 min read · updated

AI visibility is the share of AI answers that mention your business when people ask questions about your category. To check it, write the questions your customers would ask, run each one several times in ChatGPT and Gemini with web search on, and count how often you are named, where, next to whom and based on which sources. Repeat the same questions every month, because a single answer tells you very little.

This guide explains the five metrics worth tracking, a free manual method with a spreadsheet layout, why answers change from run to run, how to read an AI visibility score, and when a free or paid AI visibility checker saves you time.

What is AI visibility?

When someone asks ChatGPT "who does the best kitchen renovations in Denver?" the answer usually names three to eight businesses, with short descriptions and a few source links. AI visibility describes how often your business is in that list, and in what light.

It is related to search visibility, but it is not the same thing. A page can rank on page one of Google and still be absent from ChatGPT's answer, because the AI reads a mix of sources (review sites, directories, local articles, forums) and writes its own summary. You can also be mentioned without your website being linked at all, because the AI learned about you from Yelp or a news story.

Which AI visibility metrics should you track?

Most tools and serious guides converge on the same five measurements. Here they are in plain terms.

Mention rate

The percentage of answers that name your business. If you ask 10 questions, run each 3 times, and you appear in 9 of the 30 answers, your mention rate is 30 percent. This is the single most important number, and the most stable one.

Average position in the list

When the AI gives a list, where are you on it? First of five is better than fifth of five, because people read from the top. Treat this metric with care: the SparkToro and Gumshoe study (January 2026) found that the order of brands in AI lists almost never repeats, and the authors argued that position alone is unreliable. An average position across many answers is useful; the position in a single answer is not.

Share of voice against competitors

Out of all the brand mentions in all the answers, what share are yours? If across 30 answers your three main competitors are mentioned 20, 15 and 12 times and you are mentioned 9 times, your share of voice is 9 out of 56, about 16 percent. This shows whether you are gaining or losing ground relative to the businesses customers compare you with.

Sentiment and accuracy

How does the AI describe you? "A reliable family-run shop with fair prices" is different from "a shop some reviewers say is slow to respond". Check accuracy too: wrong opening hours, an old address or a service you stopped offering are common and fixable.

Citations and sources

Which pages does the AI link to when it answers? Group them by type: your own site, competitors' sites, review platforms (Yelp, Tripadvisor, Trustpilot), directories, news and blogs, forums such as Reddit. The sources show you where the AI is getting its picture of your market, and therefore where you need to be present.

A sixth number, traffic, sits outside the answers. In Google Analytics 4, visits from ChatGPT usually arrive with the source chatgpt.com (ChatGPT adds utm_source=chatgpt.com to many links), and other assistants show up as referrals from their domains. Some AI visits arrive as direct traffic, so this undercounts. Business owners who can claim their profile in OpenAI's Business Hub (a beta launched in November 2026, open to US local businesses) also get aggregate mention and click data from ChatGPT.

Why do AI answers change every time you ask?

Language models generate each answer word by word with a degree of randomness, and with search turned on they may pick up different web pages on different runs. Personal context also plays a part: ChatGPT can use your approximate location, and saved memories may shape answers for signed-in users.

The scale of the variation is larger than most people expect. Rand Fishkin of SparkToro and Patrick O'Donnell of Gumshoe ran 12 brand-recommendation prompts 60 to 100 times each on ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI, with help from hundreds of volunteers. ChatGPT and Google's AI returned the same list of brands less than 1 percent of the time, and the same list in the same order less than 0.1 percent of the time. The study was run with a tracking vendor and is not peer-reviewed, but its conclusion matches what anyone sees when they repeat a prompt: how often you appear is measurable, your exact position in one answer is mostly noise.

The practical consequences:

  • Never judge your AI visibility from one screenshot, good or bad.
  • Run each question at least two or three times per check.
  • Compare months using the same questions, not different ones.
  • Ask any tool vendor how many times each prompt is run and how their score is calculated.

How to measure AI visibility manually (free method)

This takes about an hour the first time and 30 to 40 minutes a month after that.

Step 1: Write 10 to 20 customer questions

Mix four types:

  • Category questions: "Best family dentist in Austin", "Where to get a road bike serviced in Leeds"
  • Problem questions: "My bike's gears keep slipping, where in Leeds can fix it this week?"
  • Comparison questions: "Is [your business] or [competitor] better for kids?"
  • Brand questions: "What do people say about [your business]?"

Write them the way people talk to ChatGPT, in full sentences with details, not as short keywords. Include your city for local businesses.

Step 2: Set up a clean test

Use a temporary chat in ChatGPT (and a signed-out or fresh session in Gemini) so your own history and memory do not influence the answer. Make sure web search is used; in ChatGPT you can turn search on for the message. If you serve a different city than you are in, include the city in the question.

Step 3: Record every answer in a spreadsheet

A simple layout (the rows below are made-up examples):

DateAssistantQuestionRunMentioned?PositionCompetitors namedHow we are describedSources cited
2026-11-03ChatGPTBest family dentist in Austin1Yes3 of 5Smile Co, Barton Dental"Gentle, good with kids"yelp.com, our site, austinmonthly.com
2026-11-03ChatGPTBest family dentist in Austin2No–Smile Co, Barton Dental, Hill Family–yelp.com, healthgrades.com
2026-11-03GeminiBest family dentist in Austin1Yes4 of 6Smile Co, Hill Family"Accepts most insurance"Google Maps, our site

Step 4: Calculate the five metrics

  • Mention rate = answers mentioning you ÷ all answers.
  • Average position = average of your positions, counting only answers where you appear.
  • Share of voice = your mentions ÷ all brand mentions in all answers.
  • Sentiment = count positive, neutral and negative descriptions.
  • Sources = count each domain cited, then group by type.

Step 5: Repeat monthly with the same questions

Keep the questions fixed for at least three months so you can see a trend. Add new questions in a separate block so they do not distort the comparison.

Free tools that help measure AI visibility

  • Bing Webmaster Tools, AI Performance report. Shows how often your pages are cited in Microsoft Copilot and Bing's AI summaries, and for which queries. Public preview since February 2026, free for verified sites. It does not cover ChatGPT or Gemini.
  • Google Search Console. Google points to its generative AI performance report for its AI features in Search.
  • Google Analytics 4. For referral traffic from AI assistants.
  • AmIPicked. Our free AI visibility checker does a compact version of the manual method in a few minutes, with no signup. You enter your website, it reads the site and writes five questions your customers would likely ask (you can edit them), then asks ChatGPT and Gemini with live web search. The result shows in how many answers you are mentioned, your average position in the list, your share of answers against competitors, how the AI describes your business, and the cited sources grouped by type. It also checks your robots.txt, llms.txt and structured data, and you can download a PDF.
  • Ahrefs' free AI visibility checker gives a one-off snapshot of brand mentions across several AI platforms with top cited domains, based on prompts from its database rather than your own questions.

Five questions on two assistants is a quick check, not a full audit. If you need more depth, the AmIPicked full report and monthly monitoring cover 20 questions across ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude with a fix plan.

When is a paid AI visibility tracker worth it?

Paid trackers run many prompts on a schedule, keep history and compare you with competitors automatically. They make sense if you track more than about 20 prompts, several markets or languages, or report to a team or client every month. Options include Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit and Ahrefs Brand Radar (strong if you already use those SEO suites), and dedicated trackers such as Peec AI, Profound and Otterly.AI. We compare them in the best AI visibility tools and Peec AI alternatives.

For a single local business, a monthly manual check or a free test is usually enough until you know what to fix.

What is an AI visibility score?

An AI visibility score is a single number a tool calculates from metrics like mention rate, position and share of voice. It is handy for spotting trends, but there is no standard formula, so a 62 in one tool and a 45 in another may describe the same situation. Use any score to compare yourself with yourself over time, using the same tool and the same questions, and look at the underlying mention rate when making decisions.

How to run an AI visibility audit

An audit adds the "why" to the measurement. After you know your numbers, check these causes:

  1. Crawler access. Does your robots.txt allow OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot, ClaudeBot and the main search engine bots? Our AI crawler checker answers this in seconds, and the GPTBot and robots.txt guide explains what each bot does.
  2. Indexing. Are your key pages in Bing and Google? ChatGPT search uses Bing among its sources.
  3. Readable facts. Are services, prices, location and hours stated in plain HTML text, with structured data such as LocalBusiness?
  4. Listings and reviews. Are your details consistent on Google Business Profile, Bing Places, Yelp and the directories in your industry?
  5. Sources gap. Which sites does the AI cite for competitors that do not mention you?
  6. Optional files. An llms.txt file is cheap to add with our llms.txt generator, but no major AI company has confirmed it affects answers, and Google says its Search ignores it. Read the llms.txt guide before spending time on it.

Then act on what you find. Our guides on how to rank in ChatGPT and generative engine optimization cover the fixes in detail.

A quick example: a bike shop in Leeds

A bike shop runs 10 questions, three times each, in ChatGPT and Gemini: 60 answers. It is mentioned in 12 (a 20 percent mention rate), with an average position of 4. Two competitors appear in 40 and 33 answers. Most cited sources are Google Maps, Yelp and a local cycling blog's "best bike shops in Leeds" post that does not include the shop. ChatGPT describes it once as "closed on weekends", which stopped being true last year.

The plan writes itself: fix the hours everywhere, contact the blog, ask recent customers for reviews, and add a servicing page with prices. Next month, the same 60 answers will show whether it worked.

That is the whole point of measuring AI visibility. The number on its own is not the goal; it tells you which fix to make first and whether it helped. If you want a starting point today, the free AmIPicked test will give you one in a few minutes.

Frequently asked questions

What is AI visibility?

+

AI visibility is how often and how favourably AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews mention your business when people ask questions in your category. It is usually measured as the share of relevant answers that name you, together with your position in lists, your share against competitors, the tone of the description and the sources cited.

How do I check my AI visibility for free?

+

Write 10 to 20 questions your customers would ask, run each one several times in ChatGPT and Gemini with web search turned on, and record whether your business is mentioned, where it appears, who else is named and which sources are linked. Repeat with the same questions every month. A free tool such as AmIPicked does a smaller version of this automatically in a few minutes.

Why does ChatGPT give a different answer every time?

+

AI models generate each answer fresh, with some built-in randomness, and with search turned on they may read different web pages each time. A study by SparkToro and Gumshoe published in January 2026 found ChatGPT and Google's AI returned the same list of brands less than 1 percent of the time for repeated prompts. That is why you should measure the share of answers that mention you across several runs, not a single response.

What is a good AI visibility score?

+

There is no industry standard, and every tool calculates its score differently, so scores from different tools cannot be compared. The most useful number is your own mention rate over time for a fixed set of questions, compared with your direct competitors on the same questions. If competitors appear in most answers and you appear in few, that gap is what to work on.

How often should I track AI visibility?

+

Monthly is enough for most small businesses. Use the same questions each time so the results are comparable, and run an extra check after major changes such as a website rebuild, a new listing or a review campaign.

What is included in an AI visibility audit?

+

An AI visibility audit combines a measurement of how AI assistants answer customer questions with a check of the reasons behind the result. That means looking at whether AI crawlers can access your site in robots.txt, whether your key information is readable and marked up with structured data, and which third-party sources the AI cites instead of you.

Read next